Dublin Book PressAuthor-led publishing

Clarity before revision

Editorial assessment

A professional, high-level diagnosis of your manuscript—what is working, what is holding it back, and where your next revision will make the greatest difference.

Request a tailored scope
A writer working at a desk during a careful manuscript review
Dublin Book Press · Author-led service

Who it is for

Writers with a complete or substantially complete draft who need objective direction before committing to a full edit.

What is included

A clearly defined professional scope.

  • Whole-manuscript review of structure, flow and reader experience
  • Assessment of positioning, audience and genre expectations
  • Commentary on opening, pacing, character or argument development
  • Identification of recurring craft and clarity issues
  • Private consultation to discuss priorities and questions

How it works

From enquiry to approved delivery.

  1. 01

    Submit the manuscript and project context

  2. 02

    We complete a structured diagnostic read

  3. 03

    You receive the report before the consultation

  4. 04

    We discuss recommendations and the best next action

Questions before you begin

Editorial assessment FAQs

Is this the same as developmental editing?

No. An assessment diagnoses the manuscript and provides a revision strategy; developmental editing works through the manuscript in substantially greater depth.

Will you edit the manuscript itself?

The main deliverable is the assessment report, though selected passages may be annotated to demonstrate recurring issues.

Can I upgrade to editing later?

Yes. The assessment can become the foundation for a later developmental or line-editing scope.

What condition should my manuscript be in?

A complete or substantially complete draft is ideal. It does not need to be polished, but the full shape of the book should be available for review.

How long will my assessment report be?

Report length varies with the manuscript and agreed scope. Your proposal confirms the deliverables and review schedule before work begins.

Request a proposal

Tell us about your manuscript.

Share the essentials and we will respond about fit, recommended scope and the information needed for an accurate proposal.

Prefer to speak with us? Call +353 1 575 4749.

Your information is used only to respond to this enquiry. Optional files are submitted securely with your enquiry.